The most common complaint about adult dating and hookup sites isn’t price. It’s paying for a membership and then realising many of the people messaging you weren’t real. Some are fake profiles meant to push you into paying, some are bots, and some are scammers after your money. Here’s how to tell the difference before it costs you.
This site is for adults aged 18 and over. This article contains no explicit content.
Three Kinds of Fake You’ll Meet
| Type | What it wants | Typical sign |
|---|---|---|
| Upsell profiles | Get you to buy a membership | Lots of attention right after you join, then silence after you pay |
| Bots | Keep you clicking or send you to another site | Generic replies that don’t answer your questions |
| Romance or money scammers | Your money or personal details | A sad story, then a request for cash, gift cards or crypto |
9 Warning Signs of a Fake Profile
- A flood of likes and visits the minute you sign up, before you’ve added a photo or written anything.
- Messages you can’t read without paying. The more “locked” messages appear, the harder the site is selling.
- Attention stops after you upgrade. Many reviewers describe exactly this pattern.
- Replies that ignore what you said, or the same opener from several different profiles.
- Model-quality photos with no casual pictures. A reverse image search often finds them elsewhere.
- A rush to move off the site to WhatsApp, Telegram, email or another link.
- Links to cam pages or “verification” sites that ask for your card.
- Any request for money, whether for a ticket, a bill, an emergency or an inheritance.
- A location that doesn’t match their story, or a profile that dodges every plan to talk or meet.
A Simple Test Before You Pay
Use the free account for a few days first. Write a real profile, then send a handful of specific messages that need a thoughtful answer. Real people reply slowly and unevenly. If nearly every profile you message visits you back within minutes, or replies in a generic way, be cautious.
Some reviewers of affair sites report testing this by messaging dozens of profiles at once and getting visits back from almost all of them within half an hour. That’s not how real people behave.
How to Protect Yourself
- Pay for the shortest plan first, and switch off auto-renewal straight away.
- Use a separate email and a virtual or prepaid card. See how to pay discreetly.
- Never send money, gift cards or crypto to someone you met online.
- Don’t share your surname, workplace, home address or private photos early on.
- Report suspicious profiles to the site, and block them.
- Keep screenshots of conversations and billing in case you need a refund.
If a whole site, not just a profile, seems fake, read our guide on how to avoid scam adult sites.
If You’ve Already Been Caught Out
- Stop replying and don’t send anything more.
- Cancel any renewal and screenshot the confirmation.
- Report the profile to the site and keep the evidence.
- If you paid a scammer, contact your bank straight away and report it to your local fraud agency.
- Ask the site for a refund if its own fake profiles misled you. Our refund guide shows how.
Which Sites Are Worth Trying?
No dating site is free of fakes, so judge sites by how open they are about billing and how easy they make cancelling. Before you join, read our safety checks on Adult FriendFinder and Victoria Milan, then compare them in Victoria Milan vs Adult FriendFinder.
Check Adult FriendFinder’s current plans →
See Victoria Milan’s current plans →
Some links on this page are affiliate links. If you sign up through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.